So I did it. I think
I think it turned out. Not exactly what I thought it would be like but im actually kind of happy with it.
Here are 2 originals
As you can see recomposing and including more of the bandshell would contribute to the visual appear.
I tried to save the dull gray light but only ended up making things worse.
Kind of dreamy but unnatural.
And try 2
A bit better but missing the punch of having actually shot with real sunset light.
I didn’t do much to the black and white image for post processing.
I simply opened it twice in photoshop from raw. The first time to get the highlights and white crisp and the second to get the dark sky nice and tonal.
I then blended the two images with layer masks and trimmed a bit. I adjusted the lens correction and used a couple approaches to try and accentuate the height of the model primarily making the image narrower in the horizontal.
Finally I converted to black and white carefully balancing the blues and cyans for the trailing fabric and then sharpened.
Overall I kind of like the black and white image. What do you think?
Would selective color work for this image? Is that overdone?
What do you think of the other post processing attempts overdone?
Any suggestions of things I missed in post production.